Comparing Area Ministry with the Strawman

What is Area Ministry?

Sometimes I hear terms like Area Ministry or the Beloved Community used in church-speak, but it is not always clear to me what they mean.  There is a small but growing body of information available on the DioCal website, some of which I am including here in my discussion. You can find it all here.  But even reading all the fine print leaves me with questions about what is the intended goal and how will it work.

An Area Ministry Introduction from Bishop Marc

Area Ministry was born out of a coordinated strategic planning effort for the Diocese of California. That effort, the Beloved Community Vision, was created by means of a year long, diocese-wide planning process that involved close to 1,000 people. The major elements of the Beloved Community Vision, adopted by Diocesan Convention to guide the life of the diocese, are these:

  • Embodied Justice: Intentionally working against discrimination based on race, gender, sexual orientation, disability or age; standing in solidarity with the poor and marginalized; and caring for God’s creation with reverence;
  • Church Vitality: Encouraging evangelism, growth, and new expressions of church; adopting missional practices of worship and outreach; collaboration between congregations; and expressing creativity and joy in the proclamation of the Gospel of Jesus Christ;
  • Rooted Spirituality: Through vital education and renewal ministries, communities of Christian discipleship, and formation in the Episcopal tradition with informed respect for other traditions;
  • Organizational Development: Emphasizing transparency, power-sharing and accountability for all diocesan leaders and structures; leadership that encompasses all orders, sorts and conditions; improving communications throughout the diocese; and revitalizing deaneries;
  • Inclusive Community: Incorporating all people without regard to race, class, gender, sexual orientation or disability, including meaningful participation of all ages — children, youth and elders; and being attentive to the prophetic voices among us.

In order to bring this vision, these hopes and dreams to life, the diocesan staff created Area Ministry, a pattern of Christian living, enacted by people at the local level, shaped by their energies, passions, the needs of the larger communities, and overall by the Beloved Community Vision elements.

Area Ministry encourages collaboration between congregations, embedded action in the local community, and the creation of a diverse Area Ministry Team. These three behaviors are supported by a Christian curriculum, LifeCycles, locally adapted by a writing and editing team of the Diocese of California and the Church Divinity School of the Pacific, and by the creation of a Rule of Life for each Area Ministry Team.

Imagining Ways for Area Ministry

To make Area ministry work, in practice, the bishop is counting on his staff to do the work in the vineyard to make it so.  Canon Barlowe is at the front lines of that work and gave the following interview to describe his understanding of Area ministry:

What is Area Ministry? Area Ministry is a mission strategy for reimagining the church and getting us back to our missional roots. That mission does not take place only in our church buildings or in isolated parochial communities, but rather in the neighborhoods and among the people around us. Area Ministry is also a strategy for evangelism to underrepresented groups in our church, particularly young adults, and to connect with the multicultural reality of our mission environment. The best way to make those connections is by cooperating with one another. We need to open the doors of our churches and look and engage outside. If we’re looking outside of ourselves, we’ll see one another as well. This is our area.

What do you mean by cooperation? Most Episcopalians experience church inside our congregations, and that’s an important aspect, but there are many other kinds of institutions that are part of our historic mission, such as Episcopal Charities, Good Samaritan Family Resource Center, and many other groups. Area Ministry is about connecting people, so it’s also important to be in cooperation with our neighbors and their concerns.

What kind of mission do you see parishes undertaking through Area Ministry? One thing we might do is to walk our talk a little bit more, and get to know our neighbors and find out what their concerns are. We need to bring the Good News to them, not just by preaching the word but by actually bringing witness through relationships and ministry. What do people need? What do they want? What are their aspirations? Some of it might be social service ministries, and a lot of it might not that far different from what we do already. We’ve been learning from an English priest, Ian Mobsby, about the Fresh Expressions movement in the Church of England, which is finding new ways of being the church. It’s not about worship, the way we Episcopalians usually think, but rather going to where the people are. One church in England went out to a skateboard park, but rather than trying to bring those young people to the church, they built relationships with them. Over time what’s developed around them is really like a church, where instead of a nave and pews there’s a skate park. Fundamentally, Area Ministry is about not being passive. I think we’re pretty good about opening our doors and then sitting back in our pews and saying “ya’ll come”; we’re not so good about opening our doors and then going out and finding where people are and bringing the church to them.

But many parishes in the Diocese of California are struggling—membership is dwindling, their buildings are falling apart, and they have trouble getting enough people to run coffee hour. What do you say to a parish like that about mustering up the strength to do this kind of work? One of the things that Jesus talked about is the reality that the more you give something away the more there is. The quickest way to lose our faith is to conserve it so much that nobody else has it, including ourselves. The quickest way to build strength and energy and faith is to give it away. It’s debilitating to put all our energy into maintenance. If all we ever did in our homes was to keep the drips from overflowing and plaster from falling in, we’d never be able to enjoy our home and it would be a dreary life. The essence of church is not the building or figuring out how to pay a staff; it really is about our lived faith out in the world. Area Ministry isn’t about figuring out ways to get more people to come in so we can keep the status quo. It’s far more subversive and radical, going back to our roots of not the gathered community, but the dispersed community, bringing the good news of God’s love to all.

What kinds of resources do you envision being shared by Area Ministry teams? We live in a consumer society, and we’re all consumers. Some families, for instance, might choose the megachurch that offers programs for them and their children rather than the small Episcopal church down on the corner. We don’t want to be like the megachurches, but how can we meet the needs of these neighbors who are looking for that variety and size of programs? Through cooperation! We could, for instance take the small youth groups at several churches and make a single more active and vibrant youth group that might meet our neighbors needs better. If we think of ourselves as one large group rather than individual churches—that is, if we really start think of our areas, and the whole diocese as being the basic unit of ministry rather than the congregation—we have the resources of the strengths of a whole group of churches. Congregations might also share administrative tasks and resources, together hiring one or two gifted, full-time staff members at just wages rather than a number of part-time personnel each working alone in a specific church.

How do those kinds of changes help people get out into the communities? It removes us from all the work that has to go into maintenance. If the vestry or bishop’s committee is suddenly freed from worrying about yet another search for a one-eighth time administrative assistant, they might have time to think about how we’re going to go out and be the church in our neighborhood. We spend a lot of time on things that most of us don’t go to church for. People don’t say they love to go to church because they love those meetings to decide how to pay for the pipes that just broke. Instead they could talk about: Gee, I really like being part of the Episcopal church because I’ve developed a set of relationships that otherwise wouldn’t have happened, I’ve seen my own life and the life of my family transformed, I’ve seen a slight dismantling of the consumerism that is the bane of our existence as my kids and my family discover new ways of relating to people that don’t have to do with stuff but with love—those are the kind of things people could talk about. Being freed from worrying about maintenance allows us to reconnect with what makes us excited about being Christians.

How will Area Ministry affect membership? We’re going to grow because of this. Growth doesn’t come because we have the best theology or the finest liturgy; it really comes through relationships. Many of us come to church because we are invited into it by people we admire or are friends with. We care about them and are in relationship with them, and we learn from them that their faith is part of who they are. That’s intriguing to us and that brings us in. Relational evangelism is something I think Area Ministry is going to really support, so we’re going to grow.

How will Area Ministry be implemented? If you’re in a congregation that seems to spend too much time just keeping things going, if you’re fatigued because there aren’t enough people to go around and there’s too many tasks to do, you’re probably ready to start turning outside. Any church that’s ready to turn outside itself is ready to start exploring Area Ministry. We’ve identified some characteristics of churches that might be ready, for instance, churches that are in search processes for new clergy or going through other big transitions, churches that are already cooperating with other churches, churches in areas that are experiencing enormous population growth. Bishop Marc and I have spoken to nearly every parish in the diocese about Area Ministry, and we’ve identified some areas that seem particularly ready. But every church in the diocese is now or soon will be ready for Area Ministry. No one is being forced into joining, but everyone is being invited into Area Ministry.

What will the experience of an individual parish be? The first thing is to accept the invitation into relationship with other churches and ministries. Then, together — through formation, through prayer, through ministry together — you will begin to understand the area and neighbors in the area. Out of that comes a discernment about new kinds of ministries and fresh expressions of the church. Every area is going to be different, as the people in every area are different. The team might begin by gathering basic information and finding out about the area. The team in east Contra Costa County, for instance, is talking to real estate people, school teachers, hospital administrators, people moving into the community, and also looking statistics and demographic information. Bringing the church into the neighborhood is also important. One of our churches is having one of their small groups, called a covenant group, not in the church but in a coffee shop, bringing their faith into a public space. Area Ministry becomes a genuine discernment model, that we’re in a deeper engagement with our neighbors so that our neighbors are telling us what they need. It’s not just a social service model, either. As Ian Mobsby reminded us in our recent workshop, spiritual poverty is as great an issue for many people in the contemporary world as other kinds of poverty. Read about one parish’s experience.

How do you do spiritual ministry without bringing people into the church? There’s no real magic to it. Most people don’t respond to authoritarian people saying, “This is how it’s going to be.” It happens through my getting to know my neighbor and sharing my own experiences and feelings, and how my faith has helped me during those times. It’s by way of sharing my life with them, not by telling them this is the kind of belief you’ve got to have.

How is Area Ministry different than community organizing? Area Ministry uses many of the insights of community organizing, and Area Ministry teams will receive training in community organizing. But the primary goal of Area Ministry is not to organize the community around some project; it is to be agents of the Good News, to invite people into relationship with God and one another. If my goal were to teach you how to play basketball, I could teach you the rules of the game and some skills for playing, and then I could say well done, and I can leave and move on to my next student. But if my goal is to play basketball with you, I will still teach you the rules and skills for playing, but I will continue to play basketball with you, and I would never leave you. We want to share our vision and experience of the Beloved Community with others. Area Ministry is a way for us to proclaim that the Beloved Community already exists, to see aspects of the Beloved Community outside the church, and to turn everyone’s attention to one another through God.

So what?

The concept of area ministry is an empowering and imaginative approach to ministry but there are still many details to be worked out about how it will affect the parishes and the work of the church.  In developing the strawman for mission and ministry budget in response to the Department of Finance Working Group I saw much to support in the collaborative ministry concept included in Area Ministry.

The differences between area ministry as outlined by the Diocese and my Strawman are more matters of ‘who’s on first’.  They both focus on collaboration between parishes.  They both encourage broader participation by the faithful in doing the work of the church.  They both seek to look beyond the church campus into the world beyond to serve those in need.

So what’s different?

  • Area ministry sees the Diocese as the driver of ministry priorities bringing together the parishes to serve “areas” of ministry it defines.  The Department of Finance Working group proposal calls for a voluntary assessment growing over time to fund area ministry goals defined through the Diocesan budget process.  In short, the voluntary assessment is merely a modified way of  doing the same mission and ministry work.  But by making the assessment voluntary it enables the parishes to vote with their checkbooks whether they like the mission and ministry services they are receiving from the Diocese.  But some fear the parishes will withhold their voluntary assessments hurting area ministry so they oppose the idea.
  • The Strawman is parish-driven joint action for area ministry asking the parishes to take the Beloved Community Vision adopted by the Convention and, working collaboratively, turn it into mission and ministry programs that best fit the needs of the participating parishes and those they seek to serve.  The strawman creates a system where the parishes must get involved in the area ministry programs or it won’t happen. It shifts the accountability for setting the priorities for mission and ministry to the front pew of the parish churches.  It says “we are the church” and if “we don’t live into our faith obligation to serve God in this beloved community and beyond it is not going to happen.”  Instead of sending their money to the Diocese in the form of a voluntary assessment and hoping for the best, the Strawman uses participation agreements  or program contracts between the parishes to turn collaboration into joint action to deliver the mission and ministry promised.  It is possible that the shared priorities of the parishes will be different than those of the Diocese might choose but that is collaboration in action.  Arguably, the smallest or weakest parishes have more to gain from the strawman than the top down area ministry strategy because they can piggyback on the work of larger parishes and share in the best program as part of an active collaborative network and mutual aid support system.

It’s the top down versus the bottom up choice of ministry styles that is the key difference. It’s the difference between doing the mission and ministry work of the church from the pews rather than waiting for the Diocese to raise money through the voluntary assessment, then determine the area ministry priorities then allocate the money to support the mission and ministry priorities of the beloved community.

What is missing in this top down approach is YOU!   We need the corporate church to live into our witness and baptismal vows, but the church needs each of us to do more than write checks.  It needs us to follow Jesus and love one another as He loved us.  We can not delegate that duty to the corporate church—we are expected to do it ourselves by investing our hearts, hands, minds and talents as well as our treasure to do the mission and ministry work of the church.

If we want to re-imagine ministry as we are called to do to create the beloved community we must sit in the front pew and commit to mission and ministry programs that live into our unbroken chain of faith.  We must own our accountability for mission and ministry.  Creating a parish-driven mission and ministry strategy places the burden where it belongs to do God’s work in the beloved community.


2 thoughts on “Comparing Area Ministry with the Strawman

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s